European Proceedings Logo

How Do Femininity and Masculinity Relate to Female Management: Evidence From Academia

Table 1: Aspects of Female Leaders in Comparison to Male Leaders

Female leaders… Author
have a transformational, democratic, and/or “web” rather than a hierarchical style of leadership and more satisfied subordinates than men managers Fagenson (1993, p. 5)
women in positions of power) display thesame characteristics as men, regardless of whether or not men are there to influence them Fillion (1997)
have nurturance, compassion, sensitivity, empathy Grant (1988)
are affective, imaginative and creative Hines (1992, p. 314)
differ contextually  (many of the so called gender differences in organizational behaviour stem directly from gendered differentials in opportunities and access to power) Kanter (1977)
are no different to their male counterparts in terms of ‘internal communication’ and ‘personnel management’; are ‘more involved with others and less task oriented than men’; hardly differ from their male colleagues in the way in which they experience power’ Krüger (1996, p. 454)
relate to interdependence, cooperation, receptivity, merging, acceptance, awareness of patterns, wholes and contexts, emotional tone, personalistic perception, being, intuition, and synthesizing Marshall (1993, p. 124)
differ contextually (gendered identities are in context more fluid and shifting than they are depicted) Reay and Ball (2000)
have “interactive” leadership style involves:encouraging participationsharing power and informationenhancing self-worthchanging self-interests for an overall goodrelating power to interpersonal skillsbelieving in better performance when feeling good Rosener (2011)
are ‘more like men than men themselves’ Schein (1975)
differ contextually (as women achieve power, qualities normally associated with femininity are modified; sensitivity varied according to status not sex, with lower status people being significantly more sensitive to the feelings of higher status people than vice versa) Snodgrass (1992)
< Back to article