Problematic Pedagogical Situations At School From The Pre-Service And In-Service Teachers’ Pespectives
Intensive progress changes in the society have a strong influence also on our education. The school climate can be influenced by the school management (a headmaster), teachers, pupils themselves and also the use of information and communication technologies (tablets, computers and their use). Pre-service students of the 1st grade of primary school meet with new pedagogical incentives during their teacher training at primary schools, pupils reactions, but also with problem situations which they need to learn to solve. The research aims to identify and describe problems in pedagogical practice from university pre-service student teachers´ point of view and to compare these with the primary school in-service teachers´ (hereinafter Primary School´s (PS)) perception. It is also important to identify the preferred way of solving problem situations by the pre-service teachers. The result is a formation of categories of contentious situations, identification of the preferred way of solving such issues from the pre-service students’ point of view in comparison with in-service teachers’ views. The findings make it clear that the pre-service teachers find the biggest problem to be the time layout of the teaching lessons and in engaging all pupils in learning. The research also shows that the pre-service teachers look for advice and help mainly from the in-service teachers and didactic experts, who teach at the Faculty of Education.
Keywords: E-learning discussionteaching practicepedagogical problem situationspedagogical mismatch
One of the most important steps leading to improve the level of education of future teachers in the system of pre-graduate preparation in the Czech Republic is to improve the level of teaching practice and its interconnection with theoretical disciplines of teaching preparation. We are often confronted with the fact that there is still little room for a deeper reflection and analysis of individual pedagogical practices (Bartošová & Václavík, 2009).
The pedagogical situation has been defined and described in professional literature. Pedagogical situations refer to a specific cases of situations that occur in the life of a school with participation of pupils, teachers and other persons who educate pupils (Sadilová, 2006). A problem situation is a new situation, where only the goal is known, and where no well-known algorithm cannot be applied for its solution (Maťuškin, 1973). If there is a different subjective point of view at a school situation from the teacher´s point of view and a pupil, a mismatch or a conflict occurs, and a so-called a problem situation occurs (Langová et al., 1992). As Hrčka (2001) states, problematic pedagogical situations may have been created by a pupil, environment or a combination of previous factors.
Information and communication technologies (ICT) play a significant role in a school environment (Bartošová & Maněnová, 2008). In terms of improvement of future teachers’ preparation, we provide Moodle electronic discussion within E-learning system in the University of Hradec Králové during teaching practice among peers, teacher trainers, trainees or also practical didactic experts. Research on e-learning in the Czech Republic, held at the Faculty of Art, Masaryk University, found in paper
Purpose of the Study
The aim of this research is to analyse problematic pedagogical situations pre-service teachers in primary schools face in the Czech Republic and compare these with the views of in- service teachers. The research also aims to identify the preferred way of solving problem situations by the pre-service teachers.
We would like to compare identification of problematic pedagogical students’ situations (difficulties with pupils’ behaviour, evaluation during classes, with problem solving of pupils with parents or with interpretation of subject topic etc.) with that of in-service teachers. It is necessary to learn about this from pre-service teachers in order to share this with their peers and the training tutor within the context of an e-learning discussion. The following questions emerge as a result of this concern: What are the categories of problematic situations for pre-service teachers and where do they look for solutions? How do in-service teachers view problem situations faced by pre-service teacher students during their training at primary schools?
Primarily, a mixed method design comprising both qualitative-quantitative research was used (Maňák & Švec, 2014). The research was divided into three parts. The qualitative research was represented by a content analysis of discussion in the E-learning environment in Moodle, from which a diagnostics of problem situations was established. This occurred within the context of continuous pedagogical practical trainings of pre-service teachers at primary schools. The problem situations have been categorized for problems linked with a) teaching of individual subjects during practical training - methodical, b) problems with pupils’ behaviour and the last area represents problems associated with c) pupils’ parents.
Based on the created categories from the above analysis, non-standard questionnaires were created to obtain data for the quantitative aspect of the research from 1st grade primary school in-service teachers in Hradec Králové and for pre-service teachers who were 4th and 5th year students of the Faculty of Education of the University of Hradec Králové. The questionnaire for the in-service teachers consisted of 10 items (4 on demographic data, 5 semi-closed and one open item). There were two questions modified based on comments and there was an option of extension of the response. The questionnaire for pre-service teacher also consisted of 10 items (4 on demographic data, 5 semi-closed and 1 open item). For the pre-service teacher sample there was no adjustment. The questionnaires were distributed in March 2018. The questionnaires had been piloted on a sample of 5 in-service teachers and 10 pre-service teachers. The reliability of the questionnaires for in-service teachers and for pre-service teacher students was verified at Cronbach Alpha = 0.79 and = 0.81 respectively.
The third part highlightes possibilities related to where pre-service teachers have recourse during solving their problems connected with practice and whom they turn to solve situations.
From these three parts, all the problem situations mentioned in the E-learning discussion were identified and categorized, while the data from the questionnaire survey of the pre-service and in-service teachers’ were compared.
The research sample consists of 24 pre-service teachers who were students from the 4th year and 40 pre-service teachers were students of the 5th year primary school teaching course, who filled a questionnaire survey. The questionnaires were given in person during a common colloquium in March 2018 (100% returned). Primary school in-service teachers completed anonymously 22 questionnaires (62.8 % returned by an electronic form) in April 2018.
Data from E-learning discussions represented further material for our research, which were obtained in Moodle both from pre-service teacher students, and faculty in-service teachers during 2014 up to2018. Also didactic experts from the Faculty of Education took part in a discussion in 2014-2017 (Table
Although in previous years, there was a slow decline in the number of participating pre-service teachers in Moodle environment discussion, an increase was noted this year 2018 to 38 pre-service teachers and 10 in-service teachers and didactic experts (which is not part of this research).
Pre-service teaches are confronted with various types of problems during their teaching practice. Our research objective was to categorize individual guidance or educational pre-service teachers’ problems and identify where the teachers look for solutions.
As stated previously, the research had been divided into three parts.
According to the scope of the paper, we focus only on selected results of the extensive research results.
Identification and categorization of pedagogical problems and situations
From the pre-service teachers’ questionnaire, information was obtained from the following items:
The field connected with
As we can see, students do face various problems. The issue which students try to solve most often, is the
The problematice sitation which students most agreed on are
On the contrary, the in-service teachers assume that student teachers face the biggest problem with
Problems related to
Further problem situations which were highlighted by respondents and were not connected with the problem of the teaching process were included into the
Respondents from the 5th year highlighted problems
In comparison with the in-service teachers, we see that they do not fall into the given categories. In fact, they perceive completely different problems, which student teachers do not consider a problem. There were nine teachers who concurred that students have
Identification and categorization of teaching problems and situations in the E-learning discussion
Within the course of Primary School Teaching, we created an E-learning environment for a discussion forum dedicated to pre-service teachers, in-service teachers and didactic experts, in order to improve the quality of pre-service teacher students’ preparation. Since 2014, they have been exchanging their observations and experience. They also send photos, write their suggestions or ask questions, search for answers and look for solutions for their professional problems. Based on these discussions, we did a content analysis throughout the period of three years focusing mainly on the monitored field of problematic situations.
A total of 145 respondents were involved in the discussion, with 237 pre-service teachers’ narrations and 19 in-service teachers’ and didactic contributions within one question area:
Similar with the questionnaire, a categorization of listed problem situations was done: a) related to teaching, b) focused on pupils’ behaviour during lessons a c) other problems.
In the category
11 respondents highlighted
In comparison with the questionnaires, we find conformity again with work with students’ voice. In the discussion forum, a new category of a question of a written preparation for teaching and dissatisfaction of students with teachers’ intervention into teaching.
Searching for answers to problem situations (from the questionnaires)
An important finding of the research was where students have recourse to problem solving situations arising from practice. Obtained information from the questionnaires is listed in the tables. The issue where students have recourse was divided into the field of teaching and pupils’ behaviour and into problems with pupils’ parents.
According to the replies in the area of teaching process, students most frequently turn to their practice teacher trainers and then to internet and to their peers as well.
During problem solving in the field of pupils’ behaviour, we assumed which was also confirmed, that students have recourse to their practical training teachers. They spend the time with them during practical training and also teachers know their students well and can give them good advice.
Students, as stated before also face \
Pre-service teachers have recourse to the in-service teachers, because they get immediate and the best solutions, according to the long term practice of teacher trainers and knowledge of the environment.
Parents and relatives who work in education represent further sources, as well as various web sites on internet can be an inspiration for teachers.
Our main research objective was the identification and categorization of problematic pedagogical situations solved by pre-service teachers during their pedagogical practice, comparison with in-service teachers’ views and searching sources and ways of solving the problematic situations by pre-service teachers.
After the in-service teachers’ questionnaire assessments, we can say with certainty, that the in-service teachers presume that the most frequent pre-service teachers’ problem is correct time line of the lesson plan. Another common problem is the engagement of all pupils in the teaching process, where students manage with certain difficulties in their outputs.
Other obstacles that the pre-service teachers face are their indistinctive speech, their nervousness and providing extra work for gifted pupils.
The pre-service students agree with in-service teachers in the questionnaire as far as the issue of lesson time structure is concerned and also engagement of all pupils in the lesson.
Based on an analysis of e-learning discussion content in the last three years, we have classified the categories of issues in the previous discussion.
During teaching practice, the pre-service teachers most often solved issues related to engagement of all pupils in activities and inappropriate behaviour of pupils during lessons in 2014. However, in 2015, the problematice situations involved implementation of interesting lessons for pupils and additional activities for the skilful (gifted) pupils.
After the overall analysis of discussions, we can evaluate the issue related to didactic point of view as the most feared and the most frequent one. The pre-service teachers struggle with difficulties such as: transmitting knowledge (curriculum) to pupils; implementation of new curriculum and creative activities into lessons. Pre-service teachers are challenged that they do not have a comprehensive overview of pupils’ knowledge in each year of school and what they should manage.
From the results is clear that teaching the 1st grade primary school should be strengthened mainly in terms of didactics of individual subjects and to gain a comprehensive overview of what students learn in individual years. It would be worthwhile to introduce a subject called communication skills with possibile mock problems solving situations which occur at primary schools. Another important addition would be participation of student teachers doing their practice to share their experiences with the students who have yet to go for their teaching practice.
As other results show, pre-service teachers look for help and advice from teacher trainers and didactic experts. We presumed correctly that problematic pedagogical situations will be solved by the pre-service teachers directly with an in-servie teacher or with a didactic expert within university seminars. Pre-service teachers also do tend to use social media and parents and try to find solutions there.
The contribution of this study relies on the knowledge gained from the questionnaire and analysis of the discussion forum during three years at Faculty of Education of the University of Hradec Králové, Czech Republic. With this information, we believe we can improve the quality of pedagogical practice and preparation of future teachers for teaching profession by sharing thee results with students, relevant teachers and didactic experts in individual areas of preparation.
This paper presents results of the Specific Research Project of the University of Hradec Králové number 2111 named: Problematic Pedagogical Situations at School from the Pre-service and In-service Teachers´ Point of View.
- Bartošová, I. & Maněnová, M. (2008). WEBCT – podpora výuky předmětu informační a komunikační technologie pro ZS1. In. Chráska, M., Klement, M., Serafín, Č. Trendy ve vzdělávání 2008. Olomouc: PdF Univerzity Palackého, pp. 54-58.
- Bartošová, I. & Václavík, V. (2009). Zkvalitnění pedagogické praxe s využitím elektronické diskuze. In. Nelešovská, A. et al. Za kvalitou vzdělávání učitelů primární a preprimární pedagogiky. Olomouc: Votobia, pp. 175-183.
- Hrčka, M. (2001). Sociální deviace. Praha: Sociologické nakladatelství.
- Langová, M. et al. (1992). Učitel v pedagogických situacích. Praha: Universita Karlova.
- Maňák, J., Švec, V. (2014). Cesty pedagogického výzkumu. Brno: Paido.
- Maťuškin, M. A. (1973). Problémové situácie v myslení a vo vyučovaní. Bratislava: SPN.
- Paidová, Z. (2011). Reflexe odborných diskuzí a výzkumů o e-learningu v České republice. [online]. DP Filozofické fakulty UM v Brně. [cit. 27. 02. 2018]. Dostupné z: https://is.muni.cz/th/110075/ff_m/DP-Z.Patiova.doc
- Sadilová, M. (2006). Vliv komunikačních dovedností a sebereflexe středoškolského učitele na řešení problémové situace ve školní třídě. Brno: Masarykova Univerzita.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
About this article
14 January 2019
Print ISBN (optional)
Education, educational psychology, counselling psychology
Cite this article as:
Bartošová, I. K., Janouchová, D., & Kleprlíková, H. (2019). Problematic Pedagogical Situations At School From The Pre-Service And In-Service Teachers’ Pespectives. In Z. Bekirogullari, M. Y. Minas, & R. X. Thambusamy (Eds.), ICEEPSY 2018: Education and Educational Psychology, vol 53. European Proceedings of Social and Behavioural Sciences (pp. 514-523). Future Academy. https://doi.org/10.15405/epsbs.2019.01.49